Hi, Lori, I feel your pain on the two-tone hair. I botched my dyi highlights, now I am Harlow on the bottom and Mouse on top. I am not an expert, but my opinion is that you should go experiment thoroughly at the makeup counter. What colors do you wear now? My guess is you are still Autumn/Winter(?)but will want to adjust a bit; whether that is darker, lighter, brighter or more muted, hopefully someone else will have more knowledge...Ladies?